Earlier this week, we went through the exercise of plotting out a best-case realistic scenario for the Eagles’ draft. Now it’s time for the other alternate universe, keeping in mind again that this is supposed to be within reason. The worst-case scenario is the Eagles trading their entire draft class for, like, Steve Belichick or something.
Round 1, No. 10: Texas RB Bijan Robinson
This is nothing against the player. Robinson is awesome. He’s ranked No. 6 on Dane Brugler’s Top 100 draft board for a reason. At 5-foot-11, 215 pounds with a 4.46-second 40-yard dash, he has the physical tools teams drool over and the production to match. He has two 1,000-yard rushing seasons to his credit, averaged 6.3 yards per carry during his time at Texas and is an accomplished receiver to boot. He’s equal parts elusive and powerful. In the Eagles’ offense, playing next to Jalen Hurts and behind a great run-blocking offensive line, he would be a front-runner to lead the league in rushing. And yet …
Even if the “running backs don’t matter” discourse has gone too far, using the No. 10 overall pick on a position Philadelphia can coax high-level production out of from average talent would seem like a waste of its chance to add a franchise pillar. Long term, the Eagles have needs at premium positions they value, such as offensive line, defensive tackle, edge rusher and cornerback. The notion that Robinson is the player who would most move the needle for the Eagles as a Super Bowl contender in 2023 is also misguided. As Howie Roseman said Thursday, they would be “naive” to expect the same level of health this season as they had in 2022. What difference would matter more for a team with Super Bowl aspirations, the gap between Robinson as starting running back and a backfield duo of Kenneth Gainwell and Rashaad Penny, or the gap between, say, starting cornerback Christian Gonzalez and Zech McPhearson? Or Paris Johnson Jr. and Jack Driscoll? Or Jalen Carter and Marlon Tuipulotu?
This is not an effort to be a buzzkill. Football is supposed to be fun and Robinson probably adds the most short-term juice of any early first-round possibility. But championships aren’t built by failing the Marshmallow test. At the very least, if Robinson is the target, a trade-down of several spots feels necessary.

GO DEEPER
Why Matt Patricia was hired and Jalen Hurts’ deal was a win: 8 Eagles pre-draft takeaways
Round 1, No. 30: Mississippi State CB Emmanuel Forbes
Forbes has an impressive history of production, with 14 interceptions in three seasons, including six as a true junior in 2022. A closer look at those interceptions is less impressive, as several came from dropped passes or bad overthrows. But let’s stipulate he has a nose for the ball. He’s still 166 pounds, which is 17 pounds lighter than the lightest of the 36 Pro Bowl or All-Pro cornerbacks over the last 11 years who were measured before the draft. With comparable players in this range at the position with better profiles (Deonte Banks, Kelee Ringo, Cam Smith, etc.), Forbes would be an underwhelming outcome. If the draft is about maximizing the odds of a series of long-shot bets, why settle on such an outlier?
Round 2, No. 62: Texas A&M S Antonio Johnson
This one is less about the player and more about the position. Safety, aside from perhaps quarterback, is historically the position the league is the worst at predicting. It has the highest percentage of its elite players in the last decade-plus drafted on Day 3 of the draft or not at all. This would also mean the Eagles would have ignored the lines of scrimmage three picks in a row at the top of the draft, which feels decidedly un-Roseman-like.
Johnson, meanwhile, is Brugler’s No. 2 safety but comes with questions about his ability to hold up against the pass. Writes Brugler: “Overall, Johnson has undisciplined tendencies and is still getting his body organized technically, but he is at his best near the line of scrimmage with his zone instincts and eagerness to drop the hammer in the run game. His play style is reminiscent of Jamal Adams (albeit in a different body type).”
Round 3, No. 94: Tennessee edge Byron Young
We know the Eagles are going to address the line of scrimmage at some point, so we’ll use this chance to pick on the misnamed Young. At 6-foot-2, 250 pounds, Young ran a blazing 4.40-second 40-yard dash at the combine, which backed up his 12 1/2 sacks in two seasons at Tennessee. But at 25, Byron Old is more like it, which would be a tough sell for someone who profiles as a rotational player at best.
“Young can be engulfed in the run game, and his rush stalls too quickly at contact,” writes Brugler, “but his energy and pass-rush flashes lead to backfield plays. Though he has limitations in the run game, he has the potential to make a living as a glorified sub-rusher in the NFL.”

GO DEEPER
Eagles 2023 NFL Draft guide: Picks, predictions and key needs
Round 7, No. 219: Michigan P Brad Robbins
The Eagles do need competition for Arryn Siposs, and maybe there’s not much space between a seventh-round pick and an undrafted free agent. But using a pick on a punter — only Brugler’s No. 3 punter in this case — in a six-player draft class would be tough to accept.
Round 7, No. 248: Georgia QB Stetson Bennett
There really is no such thing as a bad seventh-round pick, especially one this late, but my man here is almost a full year older than Hurts.
Full draft class
RB Bijan Robinson
CB Emmanuel Forbes
S Antonio Johnson
Edge Byron Young
P Brad Robbins
QB Stetson Bennett
That group means no help at defensive tackle and no bolstered depth for an offensive line that lost two of its top eight players this offseason, with another set for free agency and two more on the wrong side of 30. No linebacker help, either. Just think about that extra half-yard per carry, though.
(Photo of Bijan Robinson: Jay Biggerstaff / USA Today)









